In April 2025, the California Civil Rights Department (CRD) announced a landmark settlement involving a Black and Latino family in Oakland whose home was “lowballed” by a staggering $254,000. The appraiser’s valuation was significantly lower than an appraisal conducted just eight months earlier and $300,000 less than what the home eventually sold for nine months later.

This case is not an outlier. Despite increased federal oversight, racial bias in home valuations remains a systemic barrier to wealth-building for minority families in the USA. If you believe your home’s value was depressed because of your race or the demographics of your neighborhood, you are not powerless.

The Data: Understanding the “Appraisal Gap”

The impact of appraisal bias is measurable and devastating. According to 2025 research from the Brookings Institution and recent data from the National Association of Realtors (NAR):

  • Devaluation: Homes in majority-Black neighborhoods are typically valued at 21% to 23% less than identical homes in majority-white neighborhoods.

  • Wealth Loss: This systemic undervaluation results in a cumulative loss of approximately $156 billion in equity for Black homeowners nationwide.

  • The “Comp” Disparity: In cities like Baltimore, appraisals in predominantly Black neighborhoods are 1.9 times more likely to fall below the contract price than those in white neighborhoods.

  • Homeownership Rates: As of 2025, the Black homeownership rate sits at 44.7%, significantly lagging behind the white homeownership rate of 72.4%, a gap widened by discriminatory lending and valuation practices.

Tutorial: How to File a Reconsideration of Value (ROV)

If your appraisal comes back lower than expected and you suspect bias, your first line of defense is the Reconsideration of Value (ROV). While HUD rescinded certain borrower-initiated ROV requirements for FHA loans in March 2025, most conventional lenders (via Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac) still maintain a standardized process.

Step 1: Review the Appraisal Report for Errors

Lenders are legally required to provide you with a copy of the appraisal. Look for factual inaccuracies:

  • Incorrect square footage or room counts.

  • Missing upgrades (e.g., a new roof, HVAC, or finished basement).

  • Inaccurate descriptions of the home’s condition.

Step 2: Identify “Better” Comparables (Comps)

Appraisal bias often occurs when an appraiser ignores recent sales in your immediate area and instead pulls “comparables” from lower-valued neighborhoods with similar demographics.

  • Find 3 to 5 closed sales within the last 6–12 months that are closer to your home and more similar in style/condition.

  • Avoid using “active listings”; only use settled sales from verifiable sources like the MLS or county records.

Step 3: Document Evidence of Bias

Did the appraiser make comments about the “changing nature” of the neighborhood? Did they use distant comps while ignoring a similar home that sold next door? Note these inconsistencies. Some homeowners have successfully used “whitewashing”—removing family photos and ethnic decor before a second appraisal—to prove that the mere presence of a minority family influenced the first low value.

Step 4: Submit the ROV Form to Your Lender

Submit your findings in writing to your loan officer. The lender is responsible for reviewing your data and, if a “material deficiency” is found, they may require the appraiser to correct the report or order a second appraisal at no cost to you.

When to Seek Legal Counsel for Fair Housing Violations

An ROV is an administrative fix, but it doesn’t always solve the problem. You should contact a home appraisal discrimination lawyer if:

  1. The Lender Refuses the ROV: If the lender ignores your evidence of factual errors or blatant bias.

  2. Irreparable Harm: The low appraisal caused you to lose a mortgage lock-in rate, forced you to sell at a loss, or resulted in a loan denial.

  3. Pattern of Practice: You have evidence that the appraisal management company or lender consistently undervalues homes in your specific zip code (a modern form of “redlining”).

Under the Fair Housing Act, it is illegal to discriminate in the “appraisal of residential real property” based on race, color, religion, national origin, sex, disability, or familial status.

Conclusion

Your home is likely your largest financial asset, and an unfair appraisal is a direct theft of your family’s future wealth. As the 2025 settlements in California and across the Bay Area demonstrate, the legal system is finally beginning to hold appraisers and lenders accountable for the Fair Housing Act appraisal bias that has plagued communities of color for generations. If you have been “lowballed” and your lender is refusing to correct a biased valuation, you do not have to accept the loss. To fight back against racial bias in home valuations and ensure your property is appraised at its true market value, contact Lforlaw today to connect with expert home appraisal discrimination lawyers who specialize in Fair Housing litigation and protecting minority property rights.

Sources

  • California Civil Rights Department: Settlement News – Oakland Appraisal Discrimination Case (April 14, 2025).

  • Brookings Institution: How Racial Bias in Appraisals Affects Devaluation (Updated 2025).

  • National Association of Realtors (NAR): 2025 Snapshot of Race and Home Buying in America.

  • HUD Mortgagee Letter 2025-08: Rescinding Certain Borrower-Initiated ROV Requirements (March 19, 2025).

Receive the latest news in your email
Recent Post